Friday, July 17, 2009

Skunk Dreams

Louise Erdrich made some good points in her essay but they were far and few. Mostly I found this essay to be quite boring. Yes, she was very descriptive but was it too descriptive?Descriptive to the point where the reader starts to day dream while reading? She described the smell of a skunk multiple times which I found to be a little excessive. How many times do you need to be told about the foul smell of a skunk? She could have done with a little less description.
I got a little confused while reading it as well. She went from talking about skunks and dreams to vast open lands to game parks. She made it very hard to keep my attention on this essay. I would often find myself asking what happened to the skunk from the beginning of her writing or what does some of this have to do with the sknuk? She did tie in the skunks at the end of her essay again but from the first two pages to the last two there was nothing about skunks. It went into her love of open land and Eastern North Dakota. Maybe I missed something in my daydreaming that connected them.
But enough negative thoughts, Erdrich did have one good point that really stood out to me. She talked about a British psychotherapist named Adam Phillips. He said, "Is it impossible to imagine desire without obstacles?" That really got my attention and got me thinking about my desires. I realized that all of my desires have obstacles in the way of achieving them. Then Phillips goes on to say, "...the heroes and heroines of our fictions never know whether obstacles create desire or desire creates obstacles." That was by far the best quote in her essay because it really got me thinking--are my desires created by their obstacles or do I make the obstacles based on what I want? You could argue it both ways and I had never really thought of it in that way before. I had always just tried to figure out a way to get passed the obstacle but never about how the obstacle came to be.
Now I don't mean to be such a downer about her writting but I can't deny when I find a writting that I dislike so much. I didn't understand how dreams and skunks could inspire her to write an essay.

3 comments:

  1. I definitely agree with you on how confusing and random this article seemed to be. Like you said, I didn't really see how skunks tied the article together, and I wasn't really even sure what the main idea of the article even was. I didn't pay much attention to the quote about desires and obstacles when I read the article, but reading your post got me thinking about it as well. If there weren't obstacles in the way of our desires, then wouldn't we always have everything that we desired? Would a desire be a desire if we didn't have to fight and work for it? You brought up a good point about thinking about how obstacles came to be instead of just trying to get past them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree also, it was a pretty strange essay. There were some good points, like you said, but mostly it was confusing. I think she wanted to make a point with the skunk smell about how it's something that last lasts a long time unlike so many things, but I could've done without all the vivid descriptions too!

    ReplyDelete
  3. It was a bit of an odd essay, what with all the jumping around, although it made a bit more sense in the end. Erdrich did ramble a lot as well, although it was quite descriptive. It added a lot of character to the essay too, to give some credit to it. I agree with you for the most part nonetheless. I liked the quote you pointed out about the relationship between people's desires and the obstacles between them. It brought a bit of down to earth realism to the essay and in a way, made all the "daydreamin," as you call it, all of a sudden come together in one more coherent theme.

    ReplyDelete