Nicholas Carr had some very believable points in this essay but I don't think that they apply to everyone. Maybe it is just coincidence that some poeple, after using the internet, have low attention spans and can't read. I for one do not have that problem. I still enjoy reading and am able to do it for hours if I am so inclined. But maybe that's just me. Maybe I am one of the lucky few who can still go on the internet for hours and not lose my ability to read without always zoning out.
Carr mentioned how we no longer have to use our brains, all we need to do is click a button and all the information we are looking for will just appear on the screen. We don't even need to think but is this really true or is it actually a help? Some may argue, like Carr, that we no longer need to think. All we have to do is type in what we would like to know and there it is. But is that really true?
When you type in what you are looking for in Google it doesn't just bring up exactly what you are looking for and nothing else, it shows you multiple places with that information and more. If you were to look in a book for something you wouldn't have all of the options like you have on the web. Books don't show you different places you can look and different opinions, it just shows you one. The internet actually opens our minds to different ways of thinking. I personally think that having the internet helps to make us smarter.
Using the internet you can go from link to link finding out more and more about a variety of different things. It never gets old. My dad is always looking up new things on the web, but he still can't put down a book. His web surfing has not taken away his joy of reading.
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Carr did make it seem as though google was way easier than it actually is. Also I agree with the fact that he is lumping every single person into this category. There's no proof that everybody who uses the internet has no attention span. I think that's his personal issue, and definitely others as well... but not everybody!
ReplyDeleteYou have a great point! I don't know why, but it escaped me that he was lumping everyone together. Google really is not that easy, like you said. Great response, it made me rethink my response to Carr's article in some places.
ReplyDelete